Simson Garfinkel, Ph.D. (U.S. Census Bureau)
Michael McCarrin


Hash-based carving is a technique for detecting the presence of specific “target files” on digital media by evaluating the hashes of individual data blocks, rather than the hashes of entire files. Unlike whole-file hashing, hash-based carving can identify files that are fragmented, files that are incomplete, or files that have been partially modified. Previous efforts at hash-based carving have looked for evidence of a single file or a few files. We attempt hash-based carving with a target file database of roughly a million files and discover an unexpectedly high false identification rate resulting from common data structures in Microsoft Office documents and multimedia files. We call such blocks “nonprobative blocks.” We present the HASH-SETS algorithm that can determine the presence of files, and the HASH-RUNS algorithm that can reassemble files using a database of file block hashes. Both algorithms address the problem of non-probative blocks and provide results that can be used by analysts looking for target data on searched media. We demonstrate our technique using the bulk_extractor forensic tool, the hashdb hash database, and an algorithm implementation written in Python. Published by Elsevier Ltd on behalf of DFRWS. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (